Name: Brass Lantern Inn
Address: 11 N Water St, Nantucket, Nantucket, MA, United States
Telephone: (508) 228-4064
Rating: 5

Arriving at the Brass Lantern Inn, one is immediately enveloped in a tactile experience that speaks to the essence of Nantucket’s coastal charm. The building itself, adorned with classic shingle siding and a welcoming façade, resonates with the soft sounds of the nearby harbor, where the subtle whisper of waves sets a serene backdrop. Inside, the lobby reveals warm wood accents and polished brass fixtures that gleam softly under the gentle glow of vintage-inspired lighting, creating an atmosphere both intimate and inviting. The air is imbued with a hint of fresh sea breeze mingling with the scent of homemade cookies wafting from the kitchen, a signature touch that beckons guests to feel at home. As we navigated the property, we admired the seamless choreography of the staff, who moved with an easy grace, always ready to assist yet never intrusive. The check-in process was refreshingly swift; a few moments spent in the cozy lobby, surrounded by the mingling scents of freshly baked goods and the rustle of guests exchanging pleasantries, set the tone for our stay. We found our room on the second floor, where the muted colors of the decor and plush bedding fostered a sense of tranquility. Light filtered through the curtains in soft streams, allowing us to control the ambiance effortlessly. An elegant writing desk offered a quiet corner for reflection, while the en-suite bathroom was equipped with thoughtful amenities that elevated the experience—soft towels and luxurious toiletries that felt like a gentle indulgence. Throughout our stay, we were drawn to the communal spaces, particularly the dining area where breakfast was served. Here, the atmosphere shifted beautifully from the early morning light to the vibrant buzz of conversation, punctuated by the clinking of dishes. Guests gathered to savor a variety of freshly prepared options, from light pastries to hearty morning fare, each dish reflecting the culinary ethos of the island. The outdoor courtyard, framed by blooming hydrangeas, offered an idyllic setting for afternoon tea, with the soft sounds of laughter and conversation providing a pleasant backdrop. The hotel’s location places it within easy walking distance to both the bustling downtown and the serene beaches, making it a perfect base for exploring. As we wandered the picturesque streets, the charming shops and galleries beckoned. And for those seeking a moment of relaxation, the nearby beaches invite a leisurely stroll, where the sound of the ocean becomes a soothing companion. Our concierge recommends requesting a room on the second floor for a blend of privacy and splendid views of the courtyard, ideally timed for the early morning breakfast service to enjoy the quiet before the day unfolds.

Book on Expedia

1st Class Traveler Listing Owner

Google • Gary Schader • ★5.0 • Aug 22, 2025

My family and I have been coming to the Brass Lantern Inn for quite some time. It never disappoints. Sharon is a perennial presence and is wonderful and cheerful (all the time). I know, it's amazing! The breakfasts are excellent, the staff are pleasant and excellent, the location is very convenient to town, to the shuttles to various beaches and other locations on the island, they have beach chairs, umbrellas, towels, and buggy boards, to make your time on the beach enjoyable. The rooms are very clean and the beds are comfortable. I have no buts to this review. I plan to return yet another season in 2026.

February 5, 2026, 11:20 am

Log in to Reply
1st Class Traveler Listing Owner

Google • Uta Cicalese • ★5.0 • Oct 04, 2025

We love the Brass Lantern. Everything, from room to service to comfort level to location is perfect. While breakfast offerings are wonderful, eggs, even hard boiled, would be a welcomed addition. While the rooms and amenities are no frills, the price is right and everything was A+ and perfect for our needs. Don’t get me wrong, this place is not the white elephant, is not waterfront, offers no restaurants or shops. Sharon, the innkeeper is friendly, knowledgeable and amazing. While the inn does offer first floor rooms, rooms on the second floor, requires walking up, fairly narrow steps with a turn. We will look forward to return to the Brass Lantern for the fall Albie run.

February 5, 2026, 11:20 am

Log in to Reply
1st Class Traveler Listing Owner

Google • Cathy Riopel • ★5.0 • Oct 06, 2025

We chose The Brass Lantern for our family stay to attend our niece’s wedding. We filled 7 of the rooms. The rooms were lovely and each unique. The breakfast room and the lovely courtyard allowed the group to gather. The breakfasts were delicious and personal and the afternoon cookies a great hit with our group. The location was wonderful. Sharon and the staff were very kind and knowledgeable. We felt extremely well cared for.I would certainly love to stay there again.

February 5, 2026, 11:20 am

Log in to Reply
1st Class Traveler Listing Owner

Google • S&K Parsons • ★5.0 • Oct 17, 2025

The Brass Lantern Inn was lovely. It was close proximity to the port and downtown. The breakfast was satisfying and delicious. We had a hiccup with our ferry ride over as the high speed ferry was canceled. We brought the matter to Sharon’s attention just for future communications with guests. However, she went above and beyond in her gesture to make it right. Excellent customer service. We enjoyed their gracious hospitality. We will be back.

February 5, 2026, 11:20 am

Log in to Reply
1st Class Traveler Listing Owner

Google • CorpsOfDiscovery 1805 • ★5.0 • Nov 09, 2025

We thoroughly enjoyed our visit to the Brass Lantern in November 2025. Our room was exceptionally clean, quiet and comfortable. We enjoyed our breakfasts and as always appreciate the variety and freshness of all items. Of course we also enjoy the warm cookies in the afternoon and fresh fruit selection available all day (perfect anytime but especially for November days after some long treks across the island ). The Innkeeper, Sharon, is simply one of the best. Thank you again Sharon and the Brass Lantern Team, we are already looking forward to our next stay. (J&C R).

February 5, 2026, 11:20 am

Log in to Reply